Learning to match food and wine is not as intimidating as it might seem at first blush. It is not a jigsaw puzzle; there is no one perfect wine for a given dish which would exclude all others. And there are no hard and fast rules because everyone’s palate is different and some people might prefer taste sensations that others find less agreeable.
There is also the question of the changing equation. A cut of red meat, or chicken or fish, is not to be matched to just one style of wine. The selection of wine depends upon how the meat is prepared – whether rare or well done – what herbs and spices are used, and whether the meat has been marinated or is to be served with a sauce.
Take steak, for example. To say you must have a red Burgundy with steak begs the question. How was the steak prepared? Was it marinated in olive oil and soya sauce? Was it grilled with pepper and flared with brandy? Is it to be served with a bernaise sauce or in a pastry shell? All of these different methods of cooking would call for a different style of red wine, if you want to be politically correct about it.
But wine and food are pleasurable experiences, so you shouldn’t get anxious about what wines should go with what foods, to the exclusion of choice. The only rule is, You shouldn’t have to interrupt your conversation to stare at the wine glass and wonder what on earth possessed the host to pair the wine of his birth year with frankfurters and beans.
There are some principles that will help you to choose wines for food, whether at home or in a restaurant. Basically, once you have asked yourself two questions, the rest is just fine tuning.
Are the food and the wine the same weight?
Match the weight of the food to the weight of the wine. A light dish demands a light wine. A hearty plate requires a full-bodied wine with lots of flavor.
How acidic is the wine?
Acid cleanses the palate of various tastes, including salt (shellfish, pickles, etc.), smokiness (smoked fish or meat) and greasiness (animal fat, butter, oil).
On the other hand, the fruit in the wine (its sweetness) reinforces the sweetness in the dish and works against saltiness, smokiness or greasiness.
Once you have determined if the dish you want to serve is light weight, medium weight or heavy weight, choose a wine style that corresponds. How do you determine the weight of a wine? Look on the label for the alcohol content.
- Light-bodied wines: 8% to 10% alcohol
- Medium-bodied wines: 10.5% to 12% alcohol
- Full-bodied wines: 12.5 % to 16 % alcohol
Now ask yourself how salty, smoky or oily is the dish?
Consider the plate as a whole, not just the meat or fish. Vegetables can be highly acidic or, if glazed with brown sugar or honey, can be sweet-tasting.
Perhaps the saltiest, smokiest, oiliest dish there is is smoked salmon. It is very rich and concentrated in flavor which puts it in the heavyweight class of food. Imagine having a soft, delicate, sweet wine with smoked salmon – it’s enough to make you gag.
But match it with a full-bodied, dry white wine with lots of acidity and you have a marriage made in heaven. A dry Alsatian Gewurztraminer makes a wonderful partner. (Try it also with a dry sparkling wine, preferably champagne. Bubbles have a wonderfully cleansing effect on the palate.)
Where do you find acidic wines?
High-acid wines come from cool growing regions.
- France: Loire, Alsace, Champagne, Savoie, Jura Germany: Mosel, Rheingau, Ahr, Franken
- Italy: Trentino Alto Adlge, Friull-Venezia Giulia, Veneto
- Austria: Krems, Wachau
- Ontario, Canada: Niagara Peninsula, Lake Erie North Shore, Pelee Island
- British Columbia, Canada: Okanagan, Fraser Valley, Vancouver Island
- New York, USA: Finger Lakes, Long Island, Hudson River
- New Zealand: South Island
Fruity wines with less acidity come from hot growing regions.
- Rhône
- Languedoc-Roussillon
- Australia: Victoria
- California, USA
- Chile
- South Africa
- Sicily
- Corsica
- Sardinia
- Portugal